This list is compiled by a panel of BostonLax lacrosse experts.
| Player | Team | Position | Year |
|---|---|---|---|
| Aidan Carroll | B.C. High | Attack | - |
| Aidan Sullivan | B.C. High | LSM | - |
| Andrew Johnson | Nobles | Defender | - |
| Andrew Palleiko | Hopkinton | FO | - |
| Andrew Perry | Xaverian | Midfield | - |
| Andy DeMattio | North Attleboro | Attack | - |
| Anthony Forziati | Wakefield | Attack | 2019 |
| Blake Brookes | Belmont Hill | Defender | - |
| Blake Moxim | Hopedale | Attack | - |
| Brendan Fennell | Melrose High School | Attack | - |
| Brendan Tully | Foxborough | Midfield | - |
| Brian Piatelli | St. Sebastian’s | Attack | - |
| Brodie Rayment | Belmont Hill | Midfield | - |
| Bryan Anderson | Roxbury Latin | LSM | - |
| Caleb Hammett | Hanover | FO | - |
| Cam Rubin | Belmont Hill | Attack | - |
| Carl Callahan | Wellesley | Midfield | - |
| Carter Rice | B.C. High | Midfield | - |
| Charlie Cave – Belmont Hill | Belmont Hill | Midfield | - |
| Charlie Egan | Hingham | FO | - |
| Charlie Harrington | Westwood | FO | - |
| Charlie Weitzel | Roxbury Latin | Defender | - |
| Chi Chi Price | B.C. High | Attack | - |
| Chris Cusolito | Melrose High School | Midfield | - |
| Christian Gastonguay | Chelmsford | Midfield | - |
| Cole Biggins | Dragons | Defender | - |
| Cole Pascucci | Concord-Carlisle | FO | - |
| Collin Almeida | Falmouth | Midfield | - |
| Collin Bergstrom | Roxbury Latin | Defender | 20 |
| Conor DePiero | Medfield Senior High School | FO | - |
| Craig Yannone | St. John’s Prep | FO | - |
| Dan Donahue | Nobles | Goalie | - |
| Danny Angell | Littleton | Attack | - |
| Deven Varney | Roxbury Latin | Goalie | - |
| Dom Carter | Marlboro | Midfield | - |
| Dylan Gardner | Xaverian | LSM | - |
| Eric Raguin | Acton-Boxborough | Attack | - |
| Erik Niit | Dover-Sherborn | Midfield | - |
| Finn Garrity | Lincoln-Sudbury | Midfield | - |
| Garrett McKinnon | Scituate | Goalie | - |
| George Egan | Hingham | Goalie | - |
| Grant Latimer | Pingree | Defense | 2019 |
| Gray Thomas | Cohasset | Midfield | - |
| Hugh Curran | Needham | Defender | - |
| Hunter Gregory | Dover-Sherborn | Attack | - |
| Ian Peck | Marshfield | Defender | - |
| Isaac Tallino | Natick | Midfield | 2020 |
| Jack Barron | Longmeadow | Midfield | - |
| Jack Bowen | Concord-Carlisle | Attack | - |
| Jack Daoust | Xaverian | Midfield | 21 |
| Jack Gurney | Grafton | Attack | - |
| Jack McCordic | Medfield Senior High School | Attack | 2020 |
| Jack Sullivan | Cohasset | Attack | - |
| Jack Wood | Governor’s Academy | Attack | - |
| Jacob Alexander | Franklin HS | FO | - |
| Jake Erickson | Acton-Boxborough | Midfield | - |
| Jason Child | Needham | Attack | - |
| Jimmy Cosolito | Medfield Senior High School | Attack | - |
| Jimmy Freehill | St. Sebastian’s | Defender | - |
| Joe Goguen | Belmont Hill | Midfield | - |
| John Dixon | Nobles | FO | - |
| John Marshall | Andover | Defender | - |
| John Schofield | Medfield Senior High School | Defender | - |
| John Sula – Hingham (Union) | - | Midfield | - |
| Johnny Herlihy | - | Midfield | 2019 |
| Judge Murphy | Brooks | Attack | 2020 |
| Luke Moriarty | Governor’s Academy | Defender | - |
| Mac Fotiades | St. Sebastian’s | Goalie | 19 |
| Magnus Miller | Bromfield School | Defender | - |
| Martin Folan | B.C. High | LSM | - |
| Mason Dorr | Concord-Carlisle | Defender | - |
| Mason Fitzgerald | Cohasset | Goalie | - |
| Matt Cawley | Westwood | LSM | - |
| Matt Lazzaro | Franklin HS | Attack | - |
| Matt Rocha | Melrose High School | Goalie | - |
| Matt Suffredini | Winchester High School | Goalie | - |
| Matt Ward | Lincoln-Sudbury | Attack | - |
| Michael Allieri | Middlesex | Goalie | - |
| Michael Chabra | Austin Prep | Midfield | - |
| Michael Hauptman | Medfield Senior High School | Attack | - |
| Michael Lampert | Wayland | Attack | - |
| Michael Regan | Chelmsford | Defender | - |
| Michael Roche | North Andover | Midfield | - |
| Michael Swirbalus | St. Sebastian’s | Attack | 19 |
| Mike Hughes | Brooks | LSM | - |
| Mike Tobin | Reading Memorial High School | Midfield | - |
| Nate Laliberte | Governor’s Academy | FO | - |
| Nathan Laliberte | Governor’s Academy | FO | 20 |
| Nolan Collins | B.C. High | Defender | - |
| Nolan Houlihan | Billerica | Defender | - |
| Ollie Bernstein | Nobles | Midfield | - |
| Owen Boss | St. John’s Shrewsbury | Attack | - |
| Pat Mahoney | Rivers | Goalie | 2019 |
| Pat Ryan | Groton School | Goalie | 2019 |
| Patrick Morrison | Franklin HS | Defender | - |
| Paul D’Eramo | Burlington | Attack | - |
| Peter Blake | St. Sebastian’s | Defender | 2019 |
| Rich Joseph | Longmeadow | Attack | - |
| Ronan Doherty | Groton School | Defender | - |
| Ronan Doherty | Groton School | LSM | 2021 |
| Ryan Skripps | Rivers | Goalie | - |
| Sam Jean | Xaverian | Attack | - |
| Sam Joline | Medfield Senior High School | LSM | - |
| Sam Ward | Hingham | Attack | - |
| Shane O’Leary | Governor’s Academy | Midfield | 2020 |
| Spencer Cassell | Hingham | Defender | - |
| Teagan Alexander | Xaverian | Goalie | - |
| Teddy Komjathy | Wellesley | FO | - |
| Tim Lacroix | St. John’s Shrewsbury | Midfield | - |
| Tommy Miller | Rivers | Midfield | - |
| Torane Burton | Nantucket | Midfield | - |
| Welles Hatch | Concord-Carlisle | LSM | - |
| Will Frisoli | St. Sebastian’s | Defender | - |
| Will Hoyt ’21 | Tabor | Midfield | - |
| Will Meluski | Tabor | Defender | - |
| Will Zink | Noble&Greenough | Attack | 2019 |